Forum Discussion

dsun01's avatar
dsun01
Icon for Contributor rankContributor
4 years ago
Solved

questions when upgrade to Quartus Pro

Dear Support and Expert,

I have a project from TI, it is a Jesd204B design. the original design was in old Quartus standard edition. may be 16 or 17, first I updated to 18.1. everything seems working. there may be only 1 or 2 path over the timing constrains. but overall looks pretty good. after I bought an Intel Arria 10 dev kits. I got a Quartus Pro license, so I try to upgrade to Pro 21.3. after some minor modification in qsf file. the compilation can complete successfully, but there are thousands of timing failure. while I tracing this problem, I opened one IP/qsys called jesd_top_qsys_0, PlatformDesigner report an error message. I quoted here "Error: jesd204b_jesd_top_qsys_0.jesd_top_qsys_0: Component jesd_top_qsys 1.0 not found or could not be instantiated.

I don't understand what this means, because the project can go though all the compilation without any error message. why when I open one module in the project it report errors.


please give me some suggestion, appreciate your help.

David

  • SyafieqS's avatar
    SyafieqS
    4 years ago

    Hi Sun,


    I believe delete and re-add the IP is the best way to try and not complicated as you thought (drag and connect). Make sure you have a back up qar before make any changes. My suggestion if you are not sure what parameter, open the original design in STD, mark what parameters necessary and add them in new added IP in PRO. Then generate and compile. This should be able to fix your issue.


8 Replies

  • dsun01's avatar
    dsun01
    Icon for Contributor rankContributor
    4 years ago

    here is the image of the compilation complete image

  • sstrell's avatar
    sstrell
    Icon for Super Contributor rankSuper Contributor
    4 years ago

    You probably need to delete and re-add the IP in your Platform Designer system. The tool may not have been able to update the old version.

    • dsun01's avatar
      dsun01
      Icon for Contributor rankContributor
      4 years ago

      Hi Sstrell,

      Thank you for the reply, I am new to this platform designer, still not that confident to replace the IPs. but if it is the right way to fix the problem, I will give it a try. appreciate your help.

      David

    • dsun01's avatar
      dsun01
      Icon for Contributor rankContributor
      4 years ago

      Hi Sstrell

      I had a look regenerating the IPs, it is much more complicate than I thought, it seems to me like redesign everything, here is why. if I understand correctly, in the following picture, the blue color highlighted line is the IP, it is just a wrapper layer. you can see all the parameters are exactly same to the module under it, which is a .SV file. I am still working on the timing understanding and fixing. I just want to know does my understanding here make any sense.

      thank you for your help.

      David

  • SyafieqS's avatar
    SyafieqS
    Icon for Super Contributor rankSuper Contributor
    4 years ago

    Hi Sun,


    I believe delete and re-add the IP is the best way to try and not complicated as you thought (drag and connect). Make sure you have a back up qar before make any changes. My suggestion if you are not sure what parameter, open the original design in STD, mark what parameters necessary and add them in new added IP in PRO. Then generate and compile. This should be able to fix your issue.


    • dsun01's avatar
      dsun01
      Icon for Contributor rankContributor
      4 years ago

      Hi SyafieqS,

      I 100% believe and I am going to follow. I am relative new to the Pro and Platform Designer. I need get familiar with the design platform as much as I could, then I start to delete and update. there are two variables, one is that the original design is on 10AX115H2F34E1SG.

      I need port it to the Intel Arria 10 GX dev board. it is a 10AX115S2F45E1SG. one is the Quartus will be upgrade to Pro. any mistake in this two stage will make me loss the track.

      with the help Adzim, I can compile the design use Pro. once I make progress on the time analysis. I will start to regenerate everything.

      Thank you very much for the support.

      David

    • dsun01's avatar
      dsun01
      Icon for Contributor rankContributor
      4 years ago

      Hi SyafieqS,

      I accepted your post as solution, that is from the strategy level, now when I start the operation. the first problem I have is shown in the following screen capture.

      jest_top_qsys_0 here is a submodule of jest204b, from parameter you can see the LMF is 16, 4, 2. when I create a new jest_top. the Maximum L value is 8. the problem is that I couldn't find the jest_top_qsys_0.qsys in the project. from the detail screen capture, the author is unknown, and all description are none. I hope I can have a little bit more detail besides the strategy in this special case.

      there is only one sub-directory called synth in directory

      C:\FPGA_std18\TSWJ57\Orig\ip\jesd204b\jesd_top_qsys_10

      almost all files in synth are .sv file.

      seems I need re-generate a new .qys called jesd_top_qsys_10, but I lost the track of this module, even the project compile successfully.

      Appreciate your help.

      David

  • SyafieqS's avatar
    SyafieqS
    Icon for Super Contributor rankSuper Contributor
    4 years ago

    HI Sun,


    I believe all the files .sv mentioned is the necessary files for your sub-module of jesd_top_qsys_10. In that folder you mentioned, there should be a jesd_top_qsys_10.sv which you can use that as top file instead of qsys. Just need to include all that files in the project.