constant manipulation in VHDL statement

Question

Hi,

I am puzzled by the result of a VHDL code and hope someone could help understand the problem.

......

constant PERIOD : integer := 1000;

constant A : integer := 4;

constant B : integer := 23;

......

process

variable count : integer := 0;

......

if count < (PERIOD* (A+B )) then

It appears that the behavior of the statement above is not as I expected: "if count < (1000 * (4+23)) then".

1. Where did my 'logic' go wrong?

2. How do I find out how VHDL codes are parsed in Quartus?

Thanks

altera_forum · Answer

Are you simulating or synthesizing? If you write "if count &lt; 27000 then" the code works different?  Please, place the whole vhdl code to understand it better.

altera_forum · Answer

Your logic is correct, it should be 27000. Post the whole code.

altera_forum · Answer

--- Quote Start ---  Are you simulating or synthesizing? If you write "if count &lt; 27000 then" the code works different?  Please, place the whole vhdl code to understand it better.  --- Quote End ---    I guess I was synthesizing. I compiled the project, download the sof to DE0-NANO to run it.  Here is the VHDL code. Thank you for the help.  LIBRARY ieee;
USE ieee.std_logic_1164.all;
LIBRARY work;
ENTITY square IS 
	PORT
	(
		clk :  IN  STD_LOGIC;
		vs:	IN STD_LOGIC;			-- vertial sync
		wr_req:	OUT STD_LOGIC;		-- write request
		data:	OUT STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0)
	);
END square;
ARCHITECTURE bdf_type OF square IS 
	constant	HSYNC_PERIOD	: integer := 1056;			-- LCD horizontal period is 1056 clock cycles
	constant	HSYNC_LOW	: integer := 128;				-- LCD horizontal sync signal pulse width is 128 LCD clock cycles
	constant	H_FRONT_PORCH	: integer := 64;				-- Horizontal front porch = 64 pixels
	constant	H_BACK_PORCH	: integer := 64;				-- Horizontal back porch = 64 pixels
	constant	H_PIXELS	: integer := 800;					-- Horizontal display period = 800 pixels
	
	constant	VSYNC_PERIOD	: integer := 666 * HSYNC_PERIOD;	-- LCD vertical period is 666 horizontal line
	constant	VSYNC_LOW	: integer := 4 * HSYNC_PERIOD;		-- LCD vertical sync signal pulse width is 4 horizontal lines
	constant	V_FRONT_PORCH	: integer := 39 * HSYNC_PERIOD;	-- Vertical front porch = 39 lines
	constant	V_BACK_PORCH	: integer := 23 * HSYNC_PERIOD;	-- Vertical back porch = 23 lines
	constant	V_LINES	: integer := 600 * HSYNC_PERIOD;			-- Vertical display period = 600 lines
	
	constant	RED	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0a";
	constant	GREEN	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0b";
	constant	YELLOW	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0c";
	constant	BLUE	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0d";
	constant	PURPLE	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0e";
	constant	TURQUOISE	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0f";
	constant	WHITE	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"10";
	constant	PIXEL_OFF	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"01";
	
BEGIN 
--	Input:	
--		none
--	Clock:	
--		LCDclk - LCD clock @ 10 MHz
--	Output:
--		LCDHsyncN - signal, LCD horizontal timing 
--	Description:
--		This process generates LCD horizontal timing signal: 480 clock cycles high and 128 clock cycles low
PROCESS(clk, vs)
	variable p_count : integer range 0 to H_PIXELS;
	variable clk_count : integer := 0;
	
	BEGIN
	if rising_edge(clk) then
		if vs = '0' then
--			clk_count := ((HSYNC_PERIOD * VSYNC_LOW) - 1);		-- Vertical sync pulse width is 4 lines
			clk_count := (1056*4) - 1;		-- Vertical sync pulse width is 4 lines
			wr_req &lt;= '0';
		else
			clk_count := clk_count + 1;
--			if clk_count &lt; (HSYNC_PERIOD * (VSYNC_LOW+V_BACK_PORCH)) then
			if clk_count &lt; (1056 * (4+23)) then
				-- vertical blank period; do nothing
				p_count := 0;
				wr_req &lt;= '0';
--			elsif clk_count &lt; (HSYNC_PERIOD * (VSYNC_LOW+V_BACK_PORCH+1)) then
			elsif clk_count &lt; (1056 * (4+23+1)) then
				-- 1st display line
--				if clk_count = (HSYNC_PERIOD * (VSYNC_LOW+V_BACK_PORCH)) then
				if clk_count = (1056 * (4+23)) then
					-- 1st pixel of the line
					p_count := 0;	-- reset pixel count
					wr_req &lt;= '1';
--				elsif clk_count &lt; ((HSYNC_PERIOD * (VSYNC_LOW+V_BACK_PORCH)) + H_PIXELS) then
				elsif clk_count &lt; ((1056 * (4+23)) + 800) then
					data &lt;= GREEN;
					wr_req &lt;= '1';
				else
					wr_req &lt;= '0';
					data &lt;= PIXEL_OFF;
				end if;
			else
				data &lt;= PIXEL_OFF;
				wr_req &lt;= '0';
			end if;
		end if;
	end if;
	END PROCESS;
END bdf_type;

altera_forum · Answer

Listed below is the complete code. "if clk_count &lt; (1056 * (4+23))" works but "if clk_count &lt; (HSYNC_PERIOD * (VSYNC_LOW+V_BACK_PORCH))" does not.  LIBRARY ieee;
USE ieee.std_logic_1164.all;
LIBRARY work;
ENTITY square IS 
	PORT
	(
		clk :  IN  STD_LOGIC;
		vs:	IN STD_LOGIC;			-- vertial sync
		wr_req:	OUT STD_LOGIC;		-- write request
		data:	OUT STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0)
	);
END square;
ARCHITECTURE bdf_type OF square IS 
	constant	HSYNC_PERIOD	: integer := 1056;					-- LCD horizontal period is 1056 clock cycles
	constant	HSYNC_LOW	: integer := 128;							-- LCD horizontal sync signal pulse width is 128 LCD clock cycles
	constant	H_FRONT_PORCH	: integer := 64;						-- Horizontal front porch = 64 pixels
	constant	H_BACK_PORCH	: integer := 64;						-- Horizontal back porch = 64 pixels
	constant	H_PIXELS	: integer := 800;								-- Horizontal display period = 800 pixels
	
--	constant	DPL_LINES	: integer := 234;		-- each LCD display frame consists of 234 horizontal lines
--	constant	FB_LINES		: integer := 28;		-- LCD vertical flyback period is 28 horizontal line
	constant	VSYNC_PERIOD	: integer := 666 * HSYNC_PERIOD;	-- LCD vertical period is 666 horizontal line
	constant	VSYNC_LOW	: integer := 4 * HSYNC_PERIOD;		-- LCD vertical sync signal pulse width is 4 horizontal lines
	constant	V_FRONT_PORCH	: integer := 39 * HSYNC_PERIOD;	-- Vertical front porch = 39 lines
	constant	V_BACK_PORCH	: integer := 23 * HSYNC_PERIOD;	-- Vertical back porch = 23 lines
	constant	V_LINES	: integer := 600 * HSYNC_PERIOD;			-- Vertical display period = 600 lines
	
	constant	RED	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0a";
	constant	GREEN	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0b";
	constant	YELLOW	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0c";
	constant	BLUE	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0d";
	constant	PURPLE	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0e";
	constant	TURQUOISE	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"0f";
	constant	WHITE	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"10";
	constant	PIXEL_OFF	: STD_LOGIC_VECTOR(7 downto 0) := x"01";
	
BEGIN 
--	Input:	
--		none
--	Clock:	
--		LCDclk - LCD clock @ 10 MHz
--	Output:
--		LCDHsyncN - signal, LCD horizontal timing 
--	Description:
--		This process generates LCD horizontal timing signal: 480 clock cycles high and 128 clock cycles low
PROCESS(clk, vs)
	variable p_count : integer range 0 to H_PIXELS;
	variable clk_count : integer := 0;
	
	BEGIN
	if rising_edge(clk) then
		if vs = '0' then
--			clk_count := ((HSYNC_PERIOD * VSYNC_LOW) - 1);		-- Vertical sync pulse width is 4 lines
			clk_count := (1056*4) - 1;		-- Vertical sync pulse width is 4 lines
			wr_req &lt;= '0';
		else
			clk_count := clk_count + 1;
--			if clk_count &lt; (HSYNC_PERIOD * (VSYNC_LOW+V_BACK_PORCH)) then
			if clk_count &lt; (1056 * (4+23)) then
				-- vertical blank period; do nothing
				p_count := 0;
				wr_req &lt;= '0';
--			elsif clk_count &lt; (HSYNC_PERIOD * (VSYNC_LOW+V_BACK_PORCH+1)) then
			elsif clk_count &lt; (1056 * (4+23+1)) then
				-- 1st display line
--				if clk_count = (HSYNC_PERIOD * (VSYNC_LOW+V_BACK_PORCH)) then
				if clk_count = (1056 * (4+23)) then
					-- 1st pixel of the line
					p_count := 0;	-- reset pixel count
					wr_req &lt;= '1';
--				elsif clk_count &lt; ((HSYNC_PERIOD * (VSYNC_LOW+V_BACK_PORCH)) + H_PIXELS) then
				elsif clk_count &lt; ((1056 * (4+23)) + 800) then
					data &lt;= GREEN;
					wr_req &lt;= '1';
				else
					wr_req &lt;= '0';
					data &lt;= PIXEL_OFF;
				end if;
			else
				data &lt;= PIXEL_OFF;
				wr_req &lt;= '0';
			end if;
		end if;
	end if;
	END PROCESS;
END bdf_type;

altera_forum · Answer

VSYNC_LOW and V_BACK_PORCH are respectively defined as 4 * HSYNC_PERIOD and 23 * HSYNC_PERIOD, so  (1056 * (4+23)) and  (HSYNC_PERIOD * (VSYNC_LOW+V_BACK_PORCH)) are far from equal. I assume you meant just (VSYNC_LOW+V_BACK_PORCH) as a comparison value.

Forum Discussion

constant manipulation in VHDL statement

7 Replies

Recent Discussions

timing violation fix

Issues with downloading

Quartus Prime Lite 25.1 License Error - "Unable to checkout a license" (SALT_LICENSE_SERVER)

Quartus Prime Pro 26.1 - Where to find Documentation of new Signaltap features

Error (292014): Can't find valid feature line for core SLL_CA_HBC_T001_Hyperbus_Memory_Controller_10