Forum Discussion
Honored ContributorMAX10 FPGA versus Cyclone V
Hi,
I wrote some VHDL code for the Cyclone V FPGA with ALTLVDS_RX function. Can I use the same code for the MAX10 FPGA? Regards.17 Replies
Altera_ForumI think it would be back to the initial requirement of your design and applications. Need to evaluate if you can achieve the design in Max or need Cyclone. You can sit with your local FAE for part selection. Or you can also use the part selector tool in Altera web to assist in part selection.
- Altera_Forum
i believe cost is not your constraint as you started in cyclone V at the first place, so just stick to cyclone V, better support in feature.
imajeffNew Contributor
Professionally speaking, assuming that because I was able to buy a few Cyclone development boards (more capable than I need for most of my designs) automatically means I can afford to purchase 10,000 more Cyclone V chips just for production, would be extremely unprofessional. I'm sure you know it is very unlikely that any of my projects use exactly every feature of my development board.
I'm not saying you don't know this but: Always look at the design, once completed, and choose the less-capable chip that can handle that design with a more reasonable price. It sounds very much like this is what they were asking for.
sstrellSuper Contributor
You realize this is a 6 year old thread, right?
- Altera_Forum
By looking at the overview chapter of Max 10 and CV handbook, the smallest devices' LE is 2k (Max10) vs 25k (CIV) which seems to be significant.
- Altera_Forum
The other MAX devices are more like FPGAs than CPLDs.
- Altera_Forum
Don't get confused by MAX 10 classification as "CPLD". It's a full featured FPGA with flash configuration memory and can well keep up with previous FPGA families like Cyclone III and has quite similar logic core features.
- Altera_Forum
Agree with pororo. Generally switch from FPGA to CPLD might bump into logic resource concern.
- Altera_Forum
MAX10 is a huge downgrade in term of performance compared to cyclone V. your usage really that simple allow you for such down grade?
- Altera_Forum
I think the best would to be try out compilation with design in both device to see if can fit or not. Max 10 is of much lesser logic as compare to CV.
- Altera_Forum
Probably to save the cost of flash since Max devices support on chip memory for configuration.
- Altera_Forum
what usage you downgrade from cyclone V to MAX10??
