Knowledge Base Article

Why does the Linux* EDAC driver report "Previous Boot UE detected[0x40000]" on Agilex® 7 FPGA F and I-Series SoC FPGA devices?

Description

The Linux* EDAC driver (drivers/edac/altera_edac.c) in the SoCFPGA Linux 6.12.11-lts (and earlier versions) may print a false Uncorrectable Error (UE) message during driver probe on Agilex® 7 F/I series SoC FPGA platform, as shown below.

EDAC Altera: Previous Boot UE detected[0x40000] @ 0x0

The EDAC driver maps BOOT_SCRATCH_COLD8 (offset address0x220in System Manager, absolute address 0xFFD12220) to S10_SYSMGR_UE_VAL_OFST and treats any non-zero value as evidence of a previous boot UE event. At probe time, the driver checks:

if (dberror) { ... }

instead of properly masking with:

if (dberror & AGX7F_I_DBE_IRQ_MASK) { ... }

The valid UE sticky mask AGX7F_I_DBE_IRQ_MASK(0x30002) covers bits 1/16/17 only. When the value of BOOT_SCRATCH_COLD8 is 0x40000 in which bit 18 represents the SDM ACF DDR data rate per the Agilex 7 F/I SoC FPGA register definition, but it’s reported as a DDR UE/DBE by Linux EDAC driver by mistake.

The driver does not account for the differences among the various Agilex 7 device series or for future device families.

BOOT_SCRATCH_COLD8 bit definitions:

Bit field

Agilex 7 F/I-Series

Agilex 7 M-Series

Values / description

Usage or source

[31]

Available as scratch memory

DBE Triggered Flag

M-Series:0: DDR DBE not triggered; 1: DDR DBE triggered

U-Boot ddr_ecc_dbe_status(): evaluates DDR ECC DBE status

[30]

Available as scratch memory

DDR Init in progress

M-Series:0: DDR initialization not performed or completed successfully; 1: DDR initialization in progress

U-Boot is_ddr_init_hang() checks the bit; ddr_init_inprogress() sets or clears it

[29]

Available as scratch memory

OCRAM_DBE Error Flag

M-Series:0: error did not occur; 1: error occurred

U-Boot hps_ocram_dbe_status() returns OCRAM DBE status; ddr_init_inprogress() sets or clears it

[28:27]

Available as scratch memory

Number of IO96B instances assigned to HPS

M-Series:Written during DDR handoff data population

U-Boot update_io96b_assigned_to_hps()

[19]

Flag indicating that a CPU power domain is about to be turned on; value 1

Flag indicating that a CPU power domain is about to be turned on; value 1

F/I/M-Series:A value of 1 indicates that the CPU power domain is about to be turned on

ATF socfpga_pwr_domain_on()

[18]

ACF DDR data rate set by SDM

Available as scratch memory

F/I-Series: 0 = half-rate; 1 = quarter-rate

U-Boot sdram_mmr_init_full() uses the value to configure DDRIOCTRL

[17]

ECC_DBE_DDR1 Error Flag

ECC_DBE_DDR1 Error Flag

F/I/M-Series:0: error did not occur; 1: error occurred

ATF cold_reset_for_ecc_dbe() checks the flag; Linux sets it through the ATF SMC handler

[16]

ECC_DBE_DDR0 Error Flag

ECC_DBE_DDR0 Error Flag

F/I/M-Series:0: error did not occur; 1: error occurred

ATF cold_reset_for_ecc_dbe() checks the flag; Linux sets it through the ATF SMC handler

[1]

ECC_DBE_OCRAM Error Flag

ECC_DBE_OCRAM Error Flag

F/I/M-Series:0: error did not occur; 1: error occurred

ATF cold_reset_for_ecc_dbe() checks the flag; Linux sets it through the ATF SMC handler

Impact:

  1. No actual DDR UE event is indicated by 0x40000.
  2. The false-positive log does not trigger kernel panic, reboot, or EDAC fault handling.
  3. However, the driver executes a full register write of zero to both BOOT_SCRATCH_COLD8 and BOOT_SCRATCH_COLD9 after printing the message, which may clear other valid scratch data (ATF, SDM, DDR progress bits) used by boot software on subsequent resets.
  4. Real DDR ECC uncorrectable errors continue to be reported correctly through the runtime ECC interrupt path (ECC_INTSTATUS_DERR @ sysmgr +0xA0).
Resolution

A patch has been applied to remove the incorrect previous DBE check using the BOOT_SCRATCH_COLD8 register during EDAC driver probe.

ES-14508: EDAC/altera: Remove previous DBE check using boot scratch c… · altera-fpga/linux-socfpga@d06daa2

Related Articles
Updated 14 hours ago
Version 2.0
No CommentsBe the first to comment