Replacing an Evaluation License

I should have clarified, I'm trying to use a floating license. I was able to remove the eval license by doing a full reinstall of Quartus. Quartus still isn't able to use the license and gives this error: "Can't connect to the Intel FPGA website to check for license file updates. Verify that you have an active internet connection. To prevent the Quartus Prime software from connecting to the internet to check for updates, in the Options dialog box, on the Internet Connectivity page, turn off the options under Startup."

The server running Quartus has full internet access and doesn't use any proxies. This setup has been working without issue for the past year.

I'm able to ping the server and I get this output from lmstat

I'm using Quartus 19.1 so I think the license should be valid.