Forum Discussion

roeekalinsky's avatar
roeekalinsky
Icon for Contributor rankContributor
5 years ago
Solved

Bug report: Quartus Pro version 20.3/20.4 synthesis crashes on VHDL recursive function calls with...

Bug report:

Quartus Pro Edition version 20.3 and 20.4 crashes during synthesis ("Fatal Error: Segment Violation") on VHDL recursive function calls with a intermediate values set to a constant or to the initial value of a variable delared in the function.

This bug was first introduced with Quartus Pro version 20.3 and persists in 20.4. Versions 20.2 and earlier handle these code constructs correctly and without complaint.

To reproduce the bug, a minimal working example is provided.

Place the files example.vhd and example.tcl in a directory. In that directory, execute:

quartus -t example.tcl

I'm also attaching a resulting error log. See file log.txt.

I'm running Quartus on CentOS 8.

  • roeekalinsky's avatar
    roeekalinsky
    5 years ago

    Thank you, @KennyTan_Altera.

    Yes, it appears that this bug has been fixed. And not just in this most recent release (21.3). It was already fixed in the previous release (21.2).

    Thanks,

    -Roee

16 Replies

  • KennyT_altera's avatar
    KennyT_altera
    Icon for Super Contributor rankSuper Contributor
    5 years ago

    i manage to duplicate the crashes, will get back to you if we have a workaround on this.


    • roeekalinsky's avatar
      roeekalinsky
      Icon for Contributor rankContributor
      5 years ago

      Thanks, @KennyTan_Altera. I'm already able to work around it with a minor code change in my design. I brought this problem to your attention so that it will be fixed in Quartus. Can you confirm that this will be fixed in the next release?

  • KennyT_altera's avatar
    KennyT_altera
    Icon for Super Contributor rankSuper Contributor
    5 years ago

    Our developer will need sometimes to work on this.


    Do you mind to share with us your workaround?


    • roeekalinsky's avatar
      roeekalinsky
      Icon for Contributor rankContributor
      5 years ago

      Gladly.

      For the workaround, instead of assigning the value to a constant, assign it to a variable, with the assignment done in the body of the function. See attached.

      Note that the assignment of the value to the variable must be done in the body of the function, must not be done as an initial value assignment in the declarative part of the function, as the latter results in the same crash as setting a constant.

      • roeekalinsky's avatar
        roeekalinsky
        Icon for Contributor rankContributor
        5 years ago

        Also, oops, just noticed an error in my original post.

        quartus -t example.tcl

        Should have been:

        quartus_sh -t example.tcl

        to run Quartus in shell mode for the example provided. No need to bring up the GUI.

  • KennyT_altera's avatar
    KennyT_altera
    Icon for Super Contributor rankSuper Contributor
    5 years ago

    seems like engineering will take more times to work on the fix. I will document this bugs as the kdb with the workaround. Let me know if there are more queries on this? If no, we shall close this thread.


    • roeekalinsky's avatar
      roeekalinsky
      Icon for Contributor rankContributor
      5 years ago

      Thank you for the update, @KennyTan_Altera . Before you close this thread, please provide the Bug ID and a link to the Knowledge Data Base entry, for continuity. And if you can, please also provide an estimate of when the fix will be available in a new release Quartus Pro.

      Thanks,

      -Roee

  • KennyT_altera's avatar
    KennyT_altera
    Icon for Super Contributor rankSuper Contributor
    5 years ago

    Will get back to you by end of next week. I have create a KDB but seems like need some changes on it.


  • KennyT_altera's avatar
    KennyT_altera
    Icon for Super Contributor rankSuper Contributor
    5 years ago

    Sorry, it will still need more time. will get back to you very soon.


  • roeekalinsky's avatar
    roeekalinsky
    Icon for Contributor rankContributor
    5 years ago

    Thank you, @KennyTan_Altera.

    Yes, it appears that this bug has been fixed. And not just in this most recent release (21.3). It was already fixed in the previous release (21.2).

    Thanks,

    -Roee